oracle faster paging query

Question

I have two paging query that I consider to use.

First one is

SELECT * FROM ( SELECT rownum rnum, a.* from (
    select * from members
) a WHERE rownum <= #paging.endRow# ) where rnum > #paging.startRow#

And the Second is

SELECT * FROM ( SELECT rownum rnum, a.* from (
    select * from members
) a ) WHERE rnum BETWEEN #paging.startRow# AND #paging.endRow#

how do you think which query is the faster one?

Answer 1

I don't actually have availability of Oracle now but the best SQL query for paging is the following for sure

select *
from (
        select rownum as rn, a.*
        from (
                select *
                from my_table
                order by ....a_unique_criteria...
            ) a
    )
where rownum <= :size
    and rn >  (:page-1)*:size

http://www.oracle.com/technetwork/issue-archive/2006/06-sep/o56asktom-086197.html

To achieve a consistent paging you should order rows using a unique criteria, doing so will avoid to load for page X a row you already loaded for a page Y ( !=X ).

EDIT:

1) Order rows using a unique criteria means to order data in way that each row will keep the same position at every execution of the query

2) An index with all the expressions used on the ORDER BY clause will help getting results faster, expecially for the first pages. With that index the execution plan choosen by the optimizer doesn't needs to sort the rows because it will return rows scrolling the index by its natural order.

3) By the way, the fastests way to page result from a query is to execute the query only once and to handle all the flow from the application side.